Digital - Written by Alfred Hermida on Tuesday, October 28, 2008 11:52 - 1 Comment
Canadian judge rules linking is not defamation
A Canadian court has ruled that linking to a defamatory page is not in itself an act of defamation.
The case has been greeted by some as a landmark ruling. It centred on a defamation lawsuit launched by a former Green Party official Wayne Crookes against p2pnet and several other websites. Crookes alleged that these sites were guilty of defamation because they carried links to articles he said were defamatory.
However B.C. Supreme Court judge Stephen Kelleher decided that linking by itself is not sufficient to make a case for defamation. In his ruling (PDF), he likened linking to a footnote:
A hyperlink is like a footnote or a reference to a website in printed material such as a newsletter. The purpose of a hyperlink is to direct the reader to additional material from a different source. The only difference is the ease with which a hyperlink allows the reader, with a simple click of the mouse, to instantly access the additional material.
Judge Kelleher went on to say that:
Without proof that persons other than the plaintiff visited the defendant’s website, clicked on the hyperlinks, and read the articles complained of, there cannot be a finding of publication.
However, the ruling did come with a caveat. Judge Kelleher made it clear that:
My decision that hyperlinking can never make a person liable for the contents of the remote site. For example, if Mr. Newton had written “the truth about Wayne Crookes is found here†and “here†is hyperlinked to the specific defamatory words, this might lead to a different conclusion.
As some blogs have pointed out, linking to a potentially defamatory site may still land you in trouble. This ruling will add to the debate over the legality of linking, which has been a thorny issue in Canada and beyond.
1 Comment
Video: Dan Burnett on linking defamation case | Newslab.ca
Leave a Reply
Most Popular Content
- CHEK News wins journalism integrity award
- Social media set alight over NHL refereeing accusations
- CAJ conference focuses on innovation in journalism
- Study shows Canadians love the internet
- From: richard macdonald (grumpymacdonald@hotmail.com)
Sent: February 4, 2010...
- I dont understand NHL refereeing accusations. can you help me?...
- Of course, all very cleverly written, but not everything is so natural as it see...
- I don’t normally make comments on blogs, but this article really caught my atten...
- Awesome. I wish them all the best. They deserve it. Two thumbs up for them....
- Thanks for your comment, Bonnie. Unfortunately the voice of the viewer like your...
- I am a senior living in Thorhild, Alberta.I need the CTV local channel very much...
- Could you verify if there was a article about East Indians in Vancouver protesti...
Broadcast - Feb 3, 2010 10:57 - 0 Comments
CHEK News wins journalism integrity award
More In Broadcast
- The voice of the viewer in the fees-for-carriage row
- Video of CBC Vancouver’s new integrated newsroom
- Innovative funding model to aid global news reporting
- What Canadians think of CBC
- Who can fill Don Newman’s Politics chair at CBC?
Digital - Jan 12, 2010 18:27 - 1 Comment
Social media set alight over NHL refereeing accusations
More In Digital
- CAJ conference focuses on innovation in journalism
- Study shows Canadians love the internet
- The Tyee a model for online news magazines
- Tiger Woods CGI video prompts journalism questions
- Globe’s compelling online journalism on Humane Society controversy
Print - Oct 26, 2009 9:13 - 0 Comments
Globe and Mail’s future is written in ink and pixels
More In Print
- Measuring the content of your city’s daily paper
- Why 140 characters is so very Cartesian
- Columnist champions editors but chides ‘unmitigated’ blogs
- CBC on the trouble with newspapers
- Thinking beyond print to support investigative journalism
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=63178b4a-1bf5-4c00-b3a7-349a44c90cce)
[...] UBC Graduate School of Journalism adjunct professor Dan Burnett explains the impact of the ruling by a Canadian court that linking does not amount to publication. [...]